Think Politics

Eric Pickles MP Twitterview Transcript

December 19th, 2009 by Think Politics

Eric Pickles Twitterviewing

Eric Pickles Twitterviewing

Earlier this week we twitterviewed (interview via Twitter) Eric Pickles, the Chairman of the Conservative Party and the MP for Brentwood & Ongar.

The rules of the twitterview are simple; we ask a question in a single tweet and replies must also be in a single tweet.  For anyone who doesn’t use Twitter, a tweet is limited to 140 characters.

A transcript of the twitterview follows (questions are in bold):

.

Why have the Tories chosen Sweden as their education policy template when it’s OECD PISA scores are lower than Finland’s?
We’ve looked at models in the USA and all over the world so it is not exclusively Swedish.

Was the Chancellor right to at least try to limit the pay of bankers?
We are not opposing the plans; the banks have brought this on themselves.

Do you still believe that you need a second home to be on time for meetings?
I don’t claim second home allowance.  Individual MP’s have to be accountable to voters for their own decisions.

What are the Conservatives going to do about the Barnett Formula?
The government promised a review by last summer and we’ve heard nothing since, any changes would need to be gradual.

This past year your voting record is 53%, well below average, how do you justify this?
I’m Party Chairman, I spend a lot of time around the UK talking & listening to real people, unlike Gordon Brown, stuck in the bunker.

Will the Conservative Party repeal Ed Balls’ Vetting and Barring Scheme?
We welcome Balls’ U turn but we still want to see the detail.

If elected, what will a Tory Government do address the imbalance in the UK-US extradition arrangements?
We are going to review the imbalance of the treaty. We have opposed McKinnon’s extradition.

What will be our mission in Afghanistan under a Conservative Government?
Clarity, leadership and proper support of our troops.

With respect, that is not a mission or justification for being there. What justification do the Tories give?
Combating terrorism and bringing stability to the Afghan people.

Are you in favour of mandating open primaries for all parliamentary seats?
After 100 open Primaries & two all postal ballots, they are a big success and are the future, local choice, not mandatory.

How many seats will the Conservative Party win at the next election?
Where’s my crystal ball? It’s not in the bag yet, no complacency from us.

Come on, behind closed doors what are your expectations?
Nice try, but my last answer is my final answer!

.

Thank you to Eric Pickles MP for his participation.  You can follow Eric on Twitter via @EricPickles.  Thank you also to everyone who submitted questions.

Comments [ 3 ]

Esther Rantzen Twitterview Transcript

December 13th, 2009 by Think Politics

Esther Rantzen

Esther Rantzen

On the 9th December we twitterviewed (interview via Twitter) Esther Rantzen(@Esther4Luton).  Esther is running for Parliament as an independent candidate in the seat vacated by the Labour MP Margaret Moran who is standing down at the next election because of her role in the MPs expenses scandal.

The rules of the twitterview are simple; we ask a question in a single tweet and replies must also be in a single tweet.  For anyone who doesn’t use Twitter, a tweet is limited to 140 characters.

A transcript of the twitterview follows (questions are in bold):

Q1. What is your opinion of partisan politics?
Party politics are crucial to a Parliamentary system but independent politicians can provide vital life experience, checks and balances.

Q2. If you had been an MP is 2003, would you have voted to go to war with Iraq?
I’d like to have asked more searching questions so decisions would be based on accurate information just now coming to light.

Q2 (Cont). But is it fair to criticise politicians for trusting MI6, given the information it provided at the time?
When taking country to war, every assumption must be queried and missiles launching in 45 mins = extraordinary claim.

Q3. Where do you stand on the emerging ‘class war’ at the forthcoming election?
Can’t believe anyone would disinter bones of this dinosaur but aware we live in unequal society. Easy but archaic tactic.

Q4. As an Independent, how will you influence the Government for the benefit of your constituents in Luton South?
Using contacts, publicity & political argument as I have in past. Have hit ground running & already proving effective.

Q5. How would you tackle the UK’s budget deficit?
Target benefits. Delay IT £. Sack consultants. Encourage ideas re savings from front line workers. Re-examine taxes.

Q6. What are your views on Jack Straw’s electoral reform proposal to replace 1st past the post with the alternative vote?
Against that proposal. Too complex. As a floating voter, I believe first past the post has worked. No system is without flaws.

Q7. Should there be greater restrictions on immigration and if so, what types of restrictions?
Favour amnesty on previous immigrants & asylum seekers, but strict future points system on skills for inward. Tough but fair.

Q8. Should the government have held a referendum on the Lisbon treaty and how would you have voted in that referendum?
No. Yes.

Q9. If you could pass any law through parliament, what would that law be?
I have ideas for changing treatment of child witnesses in courts & I would look at careful legalisation of assisted dying.

Q10. Is it fair to restrict by law or through additional taxation the pay of bankers?
Fear law of unintended consequences. Bank industry crucial, its culture = appalling. Until £ repaid, fair to regulate.

Thanks to Esther Rantzen for her participation and thanks to all of our Twitter followers for their questions.  Our next twitterview is on Monday 14th December at 5.30pm with the Chairman of the Conservative Party, Eric Pickles MP.  If you have any questions you would like us to ask Eric then please email to info@thinkpolitics.co.uk remembering to make it clear in the email that it is a question for the Eric Pickles twitterview.

Eric Pickles MP Twitterview

December 2nd, 2009 by Think Politics

Eric Pickles MP

Eric Pickles MP

We will be twitterviewing (interview via Twitter) Eric Pickles MP, Chairman of the Conservative Party, on 14th December 2009 at 5.30pm.

If you have any questions for Mr Pickles you can email them to us at info@thinkpolitics.co.uk (remember that you must limit your questions to 140 characters or less) or send them via Twitter direct message @ThinkPolitics.

We have an exciting line up of Twitterviews over the next couple of months including an interview with the Education Secretary the Rt. Hon. Ed Balls MP and others.  This is an exciting format that encourages directness and we look forward to your participation.

Comments [ 0 ]

Kerry McCarthy Twitterview

November 23rd, 2009 by Think Politics

Kerry McCarthy MP

Kerry McCarthy MP

Yesterday evening we twitterviewed (interview via Twitter) Kerry McCarthy MP (@KerryMP).  Kerry is the Labour Party member for Bristol East and a Junior Whip.

The rules of the twitterview are simple; we ask a question in a single tweet and replies must be in a single tweet too.  For anyone who doesn’t use Twitter; a tweet is limited to 140 characters which will explain why some of the questions and answers are worded strangely!

A transcript of the twitterview follows (questions are in bold):

Ke
What actions have your taken in your capacity as Labour’s new media campaigns spokesperson since your appointment?

Meeting with Labour bloggers, lots of interviews, speaking at conferences, planning strategy with Labour HQ and urging MPs to tweet.

Why is partisan politics a good thing?
Politics is about choices.  By the way, policies/views, inevitably involves being partisan if you’re passionate about what you believe in.

You sat on the Treasury Select Committee from 2005. Why did it fail to regulate banks effectively or foresee the crisis?
Because that wasn’t its remit as such, credit due though to Andy Love MP who was asking about sub-prime mortgages before any of us.

The Treasury Select Committee ’s job is to examine policy of the Bank of England and the FSA. RBS ran up liabilities bigger than UK GDP while you sat. Why?
Remit is to scrutinise not manage, we asked right questions but given reassurances. Tories were calling for less regulation!

Has there been any difference between Old Labour & New Labour since Brown took over?
It’s been an artificial distinction for a long time, I think ‘New Labour’ has outlived its usefulness, we’re Labour!

What are the 3 top priorities for a re-elected Labour government?
Economy, housing, environment. Don’t necessarily need legislation, but further action.

Would UK international aid be better spent tackling poverty at home, or, given the huge budget deficit, not spent at all?
No, it’s not just a moral issue, but in UK interests too, to reduce poverty and increase security in developing countries.

But, even if it in Britain’s interests to increase security in the developing world, would the money be BETTER spent at home or saved?
Would be immoral and unwise to renege on commitment to 0.7% of GDP on aid by 2013. We are very wealthy by comparison with many.

In the event of a hung parliament would you personally be against governing with the Liberal Democrats?
I don’t relish the prospect!

The number of recorded crimes in 1961 was 807,000; in 2001 it was 5.2 million. Why has crime increased in this way?
Recorded crime stats are not the same as actual crimes, rape stats being a good example.

Regardless, crime has increased during that period… why?
Social change, economic change (e.g. more opportunities for acquisitive crime), not much point to compare with 1961, look at Labour’s record.

Social media is helping change media agenda at a national level.  It needs to go local too.  How can you help to stimulate this?
Think it’s already happening in Bristol, we have online news sites, active blogs, people on Twitter, local Facebook campaigns.

What two policies do you think could boost popular support for the Government before the election?
I don’t think you can narrow it down like that, but definitely should be focus on jobs and protecting people on modest incomes.


Thank you to Kerry McCarthy for participating in yesterday evening’s twitterview.  You can visit Kerry’s Blog at http://kerry-mccarthy.blogspot.com.

Thanks to all those who submitted questions, especially Sara Bailey, Ian Ackman, Richard Gogh, George Rathmann, @Peterpanohno, @DannyAElliot, @Mulberrybush @theday2day for their questions which were used in the yesterday evening’s twitterview.

In December we will be twitterviewing the Rt. Hon. Ed Balls MP, Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families.  If you have any questions for Mr Balls you can send them to us by direct message on Twitter @ThinkPolitics or via email info@thinkpolitics.co.uk.

Comments [ 1 ]

Transcript of Andrew Gwynne MP twitterview.

November 16th, 2009 by Think Politics

Andrew Gwynne MP

Andrew Gwynne MP

Yesterday evening we twitterviewed (interview via Twitter) Andrew Gwynne MP.  Mr Gwynne is the Parliamentary Private Secretary to the Rt. Hon. Ed Balls MP; Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families.

The rules of the twitterview are simple; we ask a question in a single tweet and replies must be in a single tweet too.  For anyone who doesn’t use Twitter; a tweet is limited to 140 characters which will explain why some of the questions and answers are worded strangely!

A transcript of the twitterview follows (questions are in bold):


Do you support a Parliament for England or at least Scottish MPs and Lords NOT voting on English only matters? 
Not simple to unpick English-only stuff as often includes Scottish/Welsh bits. I think we need to look seriously at how devolution affects England though. 

Why is there no national police target for the investigation of crimes by adults against sexually exploited children? Honestly don’t know. If a target would help police in dealing with this, then see no reason why can’t be introduced

Do you think the Hunting Act needs reform, especially with regard to the condition that flushed out animals are shot? I am opposed to hunting, do not want to see repeal of Hunting Act. If aspects not working as should be then let’s amend that.

How will the unprecedented 5000+ responses to the DCSF consultation on home education affect proposed legislation? I hope will be looked at seriously. Had a very good & ‘lively’ meeting with Stockport home educators during recess.

What is the government doing to address children’s self-worth, which is at the root of most social and educational problems? By creating opportunities for young people, not just training/education but leisure and other activities… all important.

Finland scores higher than Sweden on the OECD PISA scores. Why are the Tories copying Swedish education policy? You’d have to ask a Tory that one though I think we should look at best practice from wherever to see if we’re missing owt!

How will the use of social networking sites and twitter trending topics affect the general election campaign? In 2010 General Election probably will only be a minor form of engagement… for future elections, I think it could have a big impact.

Why do you believe it is necessary to replace Trident? Debate is moving on this because of economics. Defense is important but we should be committed to global nuclear reduction too.

So nuclear arms reduction is back on the agenda because of economics? I don’t think economics is the only reason, but yes, I think it is going to be a factor (as well as being right thing to do).

What more can we do to prepare children for the big changes they will see in their lifetime? Crumbs, can’t answer that in 140! World will change so much, we need to ensure youth have latest skills to lead change.

What two policies do you think could boost popular support for the Government before the election? Off a personal tick list probably free school meals and ending bus deregulation.

 
On behalf of the entire Think Politics team, we would like to thank Mr Gwynne for his participation and the directness of his answers.  If you want to follow Mr Gwynne on Twitter, and we recommend you do so, his twitter handle is @Andrew_GwynneMP.

Our next twitterview is Sunday 22nd November at 7pm with Kerry McCarthy MP.  Kerry is the Labour Member of Parliament for Bristol East and a Junior Whip.  If you have any questions for Kerry you can submit them to us via direct message (DM) on Twitter @ThinkPolitics, or via email info@thinkpolitics.co.uk — remember to make it clear that your message is a question for our twitterview.

Comments [ 0 ]

Andrew Gwynne MP Twitterview

November 7th, 2009 by Think Politics

Andrew Gwynne MP

Andrew Gwynne MP

On Sunday 15th November at 7pm Think Politics will be twitterviewing Andrew Gwynne MP.  Andrew is the Parliamentary Private Secretary to the Secretary of State for Children Schools and Families the Rt. Hon. Ed Balls MP.

As a reminder a twitterview is an interview which is conducted through Twitter.  Questions will be unscreened and will come mostly from Think Politics’ growing band of dedicated followers. Each question and each response much be contained within a single Tweet (140 characters) which make both questions and answers more direct.

Submit your questions for Andrew via Twitter by Direct Message to “@thinkpolitics”  or  by email to info@thinkpolitics.co.uk.  Please note that questions sent by email should be labelled ‘Twitterview’ and be no longer than 140 characters, including spaces.

To follow the twitterview live, login to Twitter from 7pm on Sunday 15th and follow our tweets @thinkpolitics using the hashtag #TPTV.  If you miss the live event, an unedited transcript will appear on this blog, which as always, will be open to comment and analysis.

If you have any questions, comments, thoughts or suggestions then drop us a line.

Categories [ Think Politics News ]

Comments [ 0 ]

Transcript of Jim Knight MP Twitterview.

November 2nd, 2009 by Think Politics

Rt Hon. Jim Knight MP

This evening we ran our inaugural twitterview (that’s an interview via Twitter for all you non-tweeple) with Minister of State for Employment and Welfare Reform, the Rt. Hon. Jim Knight MP.  A lot of questions were submitted to us by our fantastic Twitter followers (we prefer to call them friends) and a few via the Blog and email too.

An unedited transcript of this evening’s twitterview follows:

[Q1 Intro] @jimknightmp lets get started. The first question is from @thedancingflea#TPTV
[Q1]
@jimknightMP How are you working with other government departments to tackle rising unemployment? #TPTV
[Q1 Reply]
close relatinship with BIS, DCSF, DCLG in particular and it is a regular at the National Economic Council – to good effect

[Q2 Intro] @JimKnightMP Okay.. second question is from @BillyNaismith #TPTV
[Q2]
@JimKnightMP Do u share the view that ppl r only voting BNP as they r dissatisfied with mainstream parties & what would u say to them? #TPTV
[Q2 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics BIlly – there is some truth in that, we need to kkeep working hard locally on the estates showing people politics works #tptv

[Q3 Intro] @JimKnightMP okay… questions 3 is from @Quitzapple
[Q3]
@JimKnightMP Has your experience at Education helped you at Employment? How far does education help people get jobs these days? #TPTV
[Q3 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics getting good GCSEs or A Levels makes a huge difference over your working life, employers also want real work experience #tptv

[Q4 Intro] @jimknightmp… the fourth question comes from @NHSPatient….
[Q4]
@JimKnightMP PAYG users pay a premium of 20p / min to subsidise JobCentre Plus on 0845 numbers by 2ppm – when will this stop? #TPTV
[Q4 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics we are working on this. JCP makes nothing out of 0845, & the main ones free from landlines, need better from mobiles #tptv

[Q5 Intro] @JimKnightMP, Jim, this question came in via email from Craig Miller and he’s from Dorset, Craig asks… #TPTV
[Q5]
@JimKnightMP If you had to stake your reputation on passing one policy before the election, which policy would you like that be? #TPTV
[Q5 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics Wow a big q – a rapid expansion of apprenticeships to help prevent youth unemployment & compete on technical skills #tptv

[Q6 Intro] @jimknightmp… several Twitter users asked us a variation of question number 6… #TPTV
[Q6]
@JimKnightMP What do you think of the Speaker breaking centuries of political impartiality with his attack on the BNP? #TPTV
[Q6 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics I didn’t see what he said but he will have to hope, with the rest of us, that they never get into the UK Parliament #tptv
[Q6 Follow-up]
@jimknightmp As a follow-up to question 6, he told the @UKYP that the BNP were a “poison which we could well do without”…thoughts? #tptv
[Q6 Follow-up]
@jimknightmp (Q6 follow-up) but the point of the question was the issue of the speaker’s impartiality #tptv
[Q6 Reply to Follow-up]
@ThinkPolitics I agree but might put it more strongly — he has to remain impartial but that doesn’t mean saying nothing on extremism #tptv

[Q7 Intro] @jimknightmp, question 7 came in from Grace Collins via email… #TPTV
[Q7]
@JimKnightMP Would you have voted to go war with Iraq solely on the grounds of freeing the Iraqi people & why? #TPTV
[Q7 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics can be for actino to prevent genocide as NATO did in Kosovo in our first term – Iraq had not gone back to that in 2003 #tptv
[Q7 Follow-up]
@jimknightmp (follow up for Q7) sorry, but for the purposes of clarity… can you answer that Yes or No? #TPTV
[Q7 Reply to Follow-up]
@ThinkPolitics No. It was not another Rwanda or Kosovo, or even Kurdestan at that point in time #tptv

@ThinkPolitics how come you get two tweets to ask the questino I only get one for the reply? ;- ) #tptv

@jimknightmp Bet you wouldn’t ask Paxman that?!? We only ask more than one if we think we need some clarity #tptv

[Q8 Intro] @jimknightmp Okay, question 8 comes from our resident (and unhinged and cantankerous) Blogger The Paralax Brief… he asks… #TPTV
[Q8]
@JimKnightMP Which types of benefits are fairer: universal or means tested & why? #TPTV
[Q8 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics false choice – many children, many pensioners so universal fair but others better targeted so more generous for needy #tptv

[Q9 Intro] @jimknightmp Penultimate question and it comes in from nowhere (it’s our own question if you’ll forgive the indulgence)… question 9… #TPTV
[Q9]
@JimKnightMP Why didn’t Gordon Brown do something about the expenses system earlier? #TPTV
[Q9 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics difficult to believe but until Telegraph we didn’t know how bad the system had got & MPs not PMs decided their own pay! #tptv

[Q10 Intro] @JimKnightMP The final question was sent in by from Ros Kayes, the LibDem PPC for South Dorset (your constituency) #TPTV
[Q10]
@JimKnightMP Do u condone extraordinary rendition &Milibands refusal 2 provide documentation on the possible torture of BinyamMohamed? #TPTV
[Q10 Reply]
@ThinkPolitics Hi Ros – the govt is opposed to extraordinary rendition, I’ve nothing to add to what David has said on Binyam Mohamed #tptv

@jimknightmp — Jim, thanks for your time and for answering the questions — We know it’s not easy in 140 characters #TPTV
@ThinkPolitics a pleasure off to see cabinet colleagues now – I’ll recommend it! Thanks for all the Qs sorry about typing/spelling #tptv

For anyone who isn’t a Twitter user, we should explain that Twitter limits you to 140 characters (including spaces) per message.  The rules of the Think Politics twitterview dictated that all questions and replies to questions must be contained in a single tweet (message) — that explains why there are some strange abbreviations used in questions and replies.

Also, anything following the @ sign in Twitter denotes a username, for example, our Twitter user name is @ThinkPolitics.  The final thing to explain are the hash tags – hash tags are used in Twitter to allow you to track a stream of messages — for our twitterviews we use #TPTV so anyone watching the twitterview live could watch all the questions and subsequent replies by tracking #TPTV.  Our advice, join Twitter and it will all make perfect sense.

Our next twitterview is at 8pm on 13th November with Andrew Gwynne MP.  Andrew is the Parliamentary Private Secretary to the Secretary of State for Children, Schools and Families the Rt Hon. Ed Balls MP.  As always you can submit your questions to us via Twitter @ThinkPolitics, via the Blog or via email info@thinkpolitics.co.uk — remember to make it clear that your message is a question for our twitterview.

Thanks.

Comments [ 1 ]

Democracy in Action: Twitterviews@ThinkPolitics

October 27th, 2009 by Think Politics

From November 2009, ThinkPolitics.co.uk will be conducting regular twitterviews — an interview conducted on Twitter — with our nation’s politicians.  Questions will be unscreened and will come mostly from Think Politics’ growing band of followers. Each question and each response much be contained within a single Tweet. It is our view that this exciting format will make both questions and answers more direct.

Our inaugural twitterview is on Monday, 2 November at 6pm (London time) with the Rt. Hon Jim Knight, Minister of State for Employment & Welfare Reform.  Submit your questions for Jim via Twitter by tweeting “@thinkpolitics”, by email to info@thinkpolitics.co.uk, or by leaving a comment below. (Please note that questions sent by email or left in the blog comment box below should be labeled ‘Twitterview’ and be no longer than 140 characters, including spaces.

To follow the twitterview live login to Twitter at 6pm on Monday and follow our tweets @thinkpolitics. We’ll ask the questions and we’ll post the responses, so can you watch the whole thing in real time via our stream.  If you miss the live event, an unedited transcript will appear on this blog, which as always, will be open to comment and analysis.

We’ll look forward to seeing you on Monday, and in the meantime, we’re excited to see what questions you come up with.

Comments [ 2 ]

Hullo, there

October 19th, 2009 by Think Politics

So, welcome to the Think Politics blog.

Eventually, this blog will be just one small part of a much larger web project called Think Politics, which we think will rather shake up the world of British politics news and public policy. We can’t really tell you much about Think Politics for now, because it’s all terribly hush-hush, and we’d hate to have to send out our hit-squads to silence those who found out. Besides, as any burlesque dancer knows, it’s the anticipation and slow revelation that brings in the crowd.

Rest assured, though, that further news about Think Politics will appear within this blog as we get closer to the full launch date, and as we reveal each part of Think Politics one at a time, you’ll be first to get a peek.

First up is the blog. Over time, we’ll be involving public policy experts and guest writers, which we hope will create a lively forum for political and public policy debate. In the meantime, you’re just going to have to put up with The Parallax Brief, Think Politics’ resident firebrand. He’ll be posting daily on his main interests: UK politics, international affairs and foreign policy, defence, and economics and finance. You can find out more about The Parallax Brief here, but take it from us, there’s nothing he likes better than a debate, so don’t be afraid to jump in and tell him he’s talking rot (which he does from time to time) or vent your frustration at his latest polemic.

Please check back here at least from time to time, because as we say, we’ll be revealing the next stage of the Think Politics project fairly soon, and we reckon that if you’re at all interested in public policy or politics, you’ll be happy you did so.

You can also follow the latest Think Politics developments – as well as the latest politics news and opinion — at twitter.com/thinkpolitics.

Comments [ 0 ]